Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
American (Traditional) >
Posted by Sweetpea on 12/11/2006
I loved this earthy, old fashioned diner. If you like old New York, Jewish diner food, and prefer to eat at local greasy spoons with old regulars (rather than chain restaurants run by teenagers and frequented by yuppie minivan drivers), this is a great place to go. It was clean enough, though not pristine, but I found the run-down glamour and architecture of the room really charming. I had the club sandwich and coleslaw, both of which were terrific. The waiter was a gruff, curmudgeonly type who took a shine to me and was obviously pleased by how charmed I was by the place and the food; I thought he was a total sweetheart. It was refreshing to find a place that feels that real and homey in the Times Square area. There is an Olive Garden just down the street for the types who don't like this place. Go there next time.
Posted by Rob on 04/02/2006
My experience there was less than pleasant. First off, the place is not clean. Regardless that the place is old, you get the sense that the diner is not cleaner. The food is unusally greasy, even for diner food. The prices were reasonable though.
Posted by Anonymous on 12/08/2005
Sure, you could go to AppleBee's or Bennigan's for a quick pre-theater meal, but why bother, when you can have a truly NY experience? And yes the staff is a little rough around the edges, just short of rude, but this is NY, not Kansas. Besides, isn't the staff rude at Peter Luger's? Now the food ain't Peter Luger's, but the food is not terrible either, and the prices are extremely affordable. If you also want to experience atmosphere straight out of NY's past, this is the place to go. So if you want a decent meal at very good NYC prices, in a truly unique atmosphere, then eat at The Cafe Edison.
Posted by Anonymous on 11/20/2005
These are among the best blintzes in the city. The service, however, left something to be desired. Cold food, inattentive service, rude staff.
Most trips to NYC include a visit to "The Edison." We ended up there after ditching the half-price theater txts line. Since it was cold, everyone had chicken soup and split sandwiches. My fish sandwich was fine. It's a crowded and fast-pace place, which is ideal if you have lots to do. It's also very reasonable. The manager was very nice and helped me with directions. I plan to go back next trip to NY.
Posted by Bart on 09/16/2005
The wife and I dropped by to try a dessert after we had dinner. The inside was interesting with light blue ceiling and pink columns with with scroll work. It was not your typical dinner. The only negative point was the paper signs on the walls of each boothe with minimum purchase $4.15. The inside was clean.
Posted by Copper Cat on 09/10/2005
We visited the Cafe Edison after reading the reviews here and weren't disappointed. I wouldn't go as far as saying fantastic, the food was good and the aptmosphere was good too but it was pretty much the same as most NY diners - fast. It's definitely the place to go for a quick breakfast and considering the location the prices are very good. We didn't go back but that was only because we wanted to try out other diners. If staying in the Times Square area, give it a try.