Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Cafe Classico

+ SHARE
Located Upstairs
  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Delis, Sandwiches, Sushi, Kosher
  • 35 W 57th St, New York NY10019 40.7640529 -73.975819
  • (Btwn 5th & 6th Ave)
  • google maps Subway Directions
  • Phone: (212) 355-5411

User Ratings (Based on 24 reviews)

3.505
Food 3.9 Value 3.6
Service 3.1 Atmosphere 3.2

Other Restaurant Info

Phone:
work
(212) 355-5411
Fax:
fax
(212) 355-5736
Website:
www.cafeclassicotogo.com
Place Order:
Order From This Restaurant
Notes:
Delivery Take Out Corporate Accounts Catering Major Credit Cards
Hours:
Mon-Thu: 9am-10pm Fri: 9am-4pm Sun: 11am-9pm
Serves:
Lunch, Dinner
Features:
Delivery, Online Ordering, Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch Special, Take Out, Catering
Min Delivery:
10.00

User Reviews

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by Dave on 12/10/2011

    Good food, poor service

    After having similar experiences the last 5 or so times I ordered/picked up from here, I decided to share them. Service is poor. When calling for pickup or delivery, the regular person who takes the order is always, always rude. He'll cut you off and get annoyed when you ask simple questions like which side dishes come with the dinner meals. Delivery times are up to an hour sometimes, too. If I pick up instead, the food is never ready when the person who took the order says it will be, I've had to wait an extra 25 minutes in the past. And even when this happens, the staff is STILL rude! The food is good, but service will absolutely leave a bad taste in your mouth.

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by yohann on 06/30/2011

    boycott

    I work two buildings away and it's my only way to eat kosher meat for lunch. The service is so poor, my colleagues and I decided to boycott the restaurant. They are consistently late and really rude. Every day, a new story. Food is just ok and of course pricey. Stay away! Find something else!

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by Mendel on 06/29/2011

    Shocking rude staff

    Just come out of there and so upset i am reviewing it right away. The place was virtually empty (arrived 8:15pm) and were seated by a waiter who didnt really say anything. I called him over to ask for water. Sitting for 5 minutes chatting with my friend who i haven't seen in years we were approached 4 times for our order! They didn't have the stuffed mushrooms i asked for but was told its basically the same as the mini meatballs just with the mushrooms! Caesar salad arrived. Plain lettuce leaves with a slice of toasted baguette and a dressing (def not caesar) on the side. Complete joke. in the middle of eating the salad(?) the waiter comes to say that the mains are ready can he bring them. So rude! Wasnt interested in arguing wi th him so i told him to bring them. The salad was not very nice anyway as it tasted like a bottled dressing so i said i was finished with it and gave it back. Having taken it he turns and tells me to take my fork out of the bowl to use for the next course!!! We ate the mains which were ok. He then puts the bill on the table and tells us how we can pay the tips! We put all the money on the table and were talking for a bit more when he leans over to take the money. He then tells us they are closing now as he folds away table cloths. I looked and saw it was 9:30 and they close at 10! We just walked out after that. we will never return.

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by Rivka on 05/19/2011

    such a dissapointment...

    I work in the area, and this is the closest kosher restaurant for me, so for the convenience of it, I have gone there quite a few times. First of all, the prices are a bit high, even for Midtown. The service, however is where they're really lacking. On numerous occasions, I have had to argue with the waiters in order to pay credit card. Sometimes they let and other times not, which is technically illegal of them. The waiters are not particularly nice, and although coming up to the table once or twice to check if everything is ok would be perfectly acceptable, some times when I am there, I almost feel like telling the waiter to pull up a chair and join the conversation since he is constantly interrupting our meal anyway. I've had times where the waiter will come up to the table 7+ times during the course of a meal-mostly for no reason at all. It's extremely annoying, and makes it seem like they're trying to rush us out (even though the place is usually deserted). I have taken co-workers there for business meetings, and many of them have commented on this, wondering if this is the norm for kosher restaurants. If they got their act together staff-wise, the place has real potential-their food is good (sushi is really good), but like I said, the staff is a HUGE turnoff.

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by Ori on 05/06/2011

    A Wonderful Surprise

    I was looking for something kosher in the neighborhood, and a fellow Jew I asked on the street directed me here. I'm new to eating kosher, and when I saw the menu outside I was worried it was going to be really expensive. However, I decided a couple extra dollars would be worth it for a kosher meal, so I went outside. What a surprise when I found out the cajun steak sandwich I wanted was only $10, and came with a free drink, a pickle, and 2 little sides of slaw and potato salad! It was juicy, delicious, and totally worth it. I'm curious to check out more of their menu.

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by wilburscoles on 01/11/2010

    Subpar Even for Midtown

    Apparently the burgers are good. I got a mangled plate of pasta and salmon and you could smell the burnt sauce before the waiter even set the plate down. Overpriced, absurdly poorly cooked food. Do yourself a favor and go anywhere else.

  • Cafe Classico

    Posted by Malka on 08/17/2009

    Most delicious and affordable burger

    I've known about this place for years but just never bothered. I actually took two clients there today and ate one of the most delicious burgers ever. better than prime grill, really. I got the mushroom and onion toppings which just made it even more mouth watering. highly recommend it. wish it were open on Sundays to take my family there.

Advertising

Movies near Cafe Classico

City Cinemas Paris Theatre

4 W. 58th St.

New York

The Artist (PG-13)
Buy Tickets

Hot and Fresh Restaurant News Delivered Weekly

You are signing up to receive:
You may also be interested in:
Offers & Promotions
Thanks for subscribing!

You will soon begin to receive the newsletters you selected.

To enjoy more benefits and personalization available on MenuPages.com, register now!

Checkbox is required
Advertising
© 2002-2011 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer