Wow - heard so much about this place over the years- what a disappointment ! The atmosphere is cool - I will give them that - and the milkshake was very good but the burger? It was hard as a rock, and it had zero flavor - I always judge a burger by the
Burger Joint
Posted by r00mb00 on 2013-07-22
it must have gone down hill i use to like their food
ordered a panini, bread was almost burnt very dry seemed old i ended up throwing out the bread and ate the meat but it was very bland. french frys were limp. they forgot the ketchup and salt. my coworker wasn't very happy with theirs either. sor
Burger Joint
Posted by Andrew on 2011-04-14
Mediocre at best
I ordered a cheese burger and it was nothing special at all--I could make the same thing at home. I also ordered a milk shake only to be told they don't start making them until later. It was the middle of the afternoon when I was there. Wait until lat
Burger Joint
Posted by BrooklynGirl on 2011-02-14
Great Burger
A colleague of mine took me to this great burger spot. The burger was juicy and definitely had a great taste.
Get there early if you are looking for a seat but if you are looking for take out this is definitely the place to grab a delicious bite!
Burger Joint
Posted by Happy Diners on 2010-06-03
Good But Not Great
Their cheeseburger is good but the portion isn't generous, so we always have to add another burger, a packet of fries (we really dislike their fries) or share a milkshake (which btw, is too sweet for our liking) and be prepared to wait in line to get to t
Burger Joint
Posted by Hamdyq on 2010-01-25
Stop all the crying
Their burgers are great, when you are a ntive new yorker you tend to learn that you get what you pay for, and for 12 bucks this order of cheeseburger and fries were and always will be awesome
Burger Joint
Posted by Marie on 2009-12-14
Left me still looking for an amazing midtown burger
A good burger, yes. A burger that was memorable and leaves me watering-at-the-mouth to have it again, no.
Loved the atmosphere, though. Playing on the speakers was everything from Big Band to Bob Marley, and there's a really nice coziness to the plac
Burger Joint
Posted by ELSA on 2009-05-20
Good burger...but clean the grill already
Burger Joint has a wonderful "authentic" NY feel. It provokes nostalgia for a long gone NY which was alot grubbier but a whole lot more fun than the fake glitz of today's midtown. Service is brusque as it should be in greasy burger joint. The fries are
Posted by Gramfood on 2014-04-03
Overhyped
Wow - heard so much about this place over the years- what a disappointment ! The atmosphere is cool - I will give them that - and the milkshake was very good but the burger? It was hard as a rock, and it had zero flavor - I always judge a burger by the
Posted by r00mb00 on 2013-07-22
it must have gone down hill i use to like their food
ordered a panini, bread was almost burnt very dry seemed old i ended up throwing out the bread and ate the meat but it was very bland. french frys were limp. they forgot the ketchup and salt. my coworker wasn't very happy with theirs either. sor
Posted by Andrew on 2011-04-14
Mediocre at best
I ordered a cheese burger and it was nothing special at all--I could make the same thing at home. I also ordered a milk shake only to be told they don't start making them until later. It was the middle of the afternoon when I was there. Wait until lat
Posted by BrooklynGirl on 2011-02-14
Great Burger
A colleague of mine took me to this great burger spot. The burger was juicy and definitely had a great taste. Get there early if you are looking for a seat but if you are looking for take out this is definitely the place to grab a delicious bite!
Posted by Happy Diners on 2010-06-03
Good But Not Great
Their cheeseburger is good but the portion isn't generous, so we always have to add another burger, a packet of fries (we really dislike their fries) or share a milkshake (which btw, is too sweet for our liking) and be prepared to wait in line to get to t
Posted by Hamdyq on 2010-01-25
Stop all the crying
Their burgers are great, when you are a ntive new yorker you tend to learn that you get what you pay for, and for 12 bucks this order of cheeseburger and fries were and always will be awesome
Posted by Marie on 2009-12-14
Left me still looking for an amazing midtown burger
A good burger, yes. A burger that was memorable and leaves me watering-at-the-mouth to have it again, no. Loved the atmosphere, though. Playing on the speakers was everything from Big Band to Bob Marley, and there's a really nice coziness to the plac
Posted by ELSA on 2009-05-20
Good burger...but clean the grill already
Burger Joint has a wonderful "authentic" NY feel. It provokes nostalgia for a long gone NY which was alot grubbier but a whole lot more fun than the fake glitz of today's midtown. Service is brusque as it should be in greasy burger joint. The fries are