Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Brother Jimmy's

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Barbecue, Southern & Soul
  • 416 8th Ave, New York NY10001 40.750059 -73.994596
  • (At 31st St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 967-7603
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 20 reviews)

Food 2.6 Value 2.5
Service 2.5 Atmosphere 2.4

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 967-7603
Place Order:
Order From Brother Jimmy's for delivery & takeout
Major Credit Cards
Mon-Thu: 11:30am-12am Fri-Sat: 11:30am-1am Sun: 11:30am-11pm
Lunch, Dinner
Open Late, Happy Hour, Bar Scene, Delivery, Online Reservations, Online Ordering, Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch Special, Take Out, Catering
Delivery Area:
25th St to 41st St 6th Ave to 10th Ave

User Reviews

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by bummin on 12/11/2013

    Soggy Fries

    I've ordered from Brother Jimmy's a 3-4 times. The meat is ok. But the fries are are terrible. Every time I've ordered, the fries are a flimsy unedible mess of grease and sadness.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Abby on 09/12/2013

    Great burger, but . . .

    Excellent burger, cooked exactly to order. Instead of my requested extra pickles, didn't get enough to half-cover the meat. Fries ordered extra crispy were vey limp, though looked well-done. Must have sat around a while. Problems were correctd, but very slowly.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Jane M. on 10/19/2010

    2nd try.... a definite No Go!

    I've been to Brother Jimmy's BBQ about a year ago, and just happen to be at the Rangers game at MSG on Monday night 10/18/10. As per my good experience last time I decided to have dinner with my boyfriend while bragging about it. We got ID'd at the entrance and proceeded to the second floor since hostess was no where to be found (2 more customers did the same). Once on the 2nd floor we were told the hostess needed to sit us (they were courteous enough to get her). Come to find out the SAME hostess was standing right NEXT to the bouncer and watched us walk without acknowledging our presence. Finally it was time to order. As I prepared to order a drink I was told drink menus are not available (because they all got dirty and had to be thrown out). I ordered my usual. We asked for another minute to look over the menu. Once she took our order more customers were seated. We asked for our food to be all out at the same time. What we didn’t expect is for our food to arrive after others were half way done, half of the 2nd quarter AND half time of football game was over. (Not even a courtesy: "Your food will be out shortly" from the waitress). Half of my Catfish Po’Boy must have been eaten on the way to the table and the BBQ chicken sandwich was replaced by a rubber. 25 minute wait for that? This was my LAST visit there. Money better off spend elsewhere.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Anonymous on 05/29/2010

    i'll pass

    i've had better bbq/southern cooking at other restaurants in manhattan. the menu is expensive. portions are small. the wait for a table is long. better restaurants around msg. don't waster your time here.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Mike on 03/13/2009

    Avoid Take Out

    I ordered take out and when I got home the sides were missing. I called the restaurant and asked them to send them to me. As soon as possible turned out to be an hour later. When the deliveryman arrived he tried to charge me and had the wrong sides. I was then told it was very busy because of the big game. The manager kindly gave me a credit but my meal was ruined.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Luke on 12/23/2008

    Good food, reasonable prices, friendly

    We had a large table here. Waitress was a little too perky but informative. Service was pretty good. Food was as ordered. Clean plates all around and plenty of leftovers. Excellent potato salad! Music a bit on the loud side, but can't beat the price, location, quality and speed as we were in a bit of a hurry.

  • Brother Jimmy's

    Posted by Laura on 12/07/2008

    Poor Choice for Delivery

    Do not order delivery from this place. They are not set up to handle take out orders. We live only 4 blocks away and it took us 2 hours to get our food, and when it arrived it was ice cold. Save yourself the aggravation and order somewhere else.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.