Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Brother Jimmy's

+ SHARE
Murray Hill
  • $$$
  • Barbecue, Southern & Soul
  • 181 Lexington Ave, New York NY10016 40.7445369 -73.9810166
  • (At 31st St)
  • google maps Subway Directions
  • Phone: (212) 779-7427

Lunch

Beginnings

Hush Puppies with maple butter   7.25
Frickles with horseradish sauce   7.95
Peel & Eat Shrimp with lemon & old bay   12.50
Popcorn Shrimp with cajun mayo   9.75
Spinach And Artichoke Dip    10.25
Jalapeño Poppers homemade & stuffed with a mixture of cream cheese & spices served with ranch dressing   9.25
Jimmy’s Burger Shack ‘Minis’ choose one style: "3 per order" cheeseburgers turkey burgers fried buffalo chicken sliders   10.50
Rib Tips northern style   9.50
Bucket O’ Tips    17.50
Hot Wings buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked   9.95
Bucket O’ Hot Wings    17.50
BBQ Wings two part wing smoked & grilled in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   10.50
Quesadilla with salsa & sour cream pulled pork or bbq grilled chicken   9.50
Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Humongous chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole   12.50

Salads & Stews

House Salad    6.95
add chicken any style   3.00
add pulled pork   4.00
Chopped Cobb Salad lettuce, onion, tomato, buckboard bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken   12.95
The Wright Salad romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette   10.95
add grilled chicken   3.00
Brunswick Stew a tomato based southern stew with corn, smoked chicken & pork   5.75

Sandwiches N’ Burgers

With 1 Side And Pickles

Pulled Pork Wrap pulled pork, pickles & slaw   9.25
Pulled Chicken Wrap pulled chicken, bacon & cheddar   8.75
Smoked Turkey Wrap avocado, house smoked turkey, shredded lettuce & honey mustard   9.25
Burgers    9.75
add chili, bacon or cheese   1.00
BJ’s BBQ Burger grilled with chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped with onion straws   10.75
BBQ Grilled Chicken basted with bbq sauce on a roll with lettuce, tomato & onion   9.95
Po’ Boys blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread with lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo   10.75
Fried Chicken buffalo style or original on a roll   10.25
Press‘D Bourbon BBQ Brisket with bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast   10.75
Brother Jimmy’s Cuban sliced smoked pork, buckboard bacon, gruyere cheese & frickles   9.25
B.L.T. applewood bacon, lettuce & fried green tomato on country white bread   8.75

Sandwiches

With 1 Side And Pickles, Slaw $0.50 Extra

Carolina Pulled Pork    10.50
Pulled Chicken    10.50
Sliced Brisket lean or marbled   10.75
BBQ Meatloaf on grilled texas toast with tomato   10.25

Lunch Entrees

Steak N’ Fries grilled skirt steak with homemade steak sauce & hand cut fries   20.50
Blackened Catfish collard greens & mac n’ cheese   17.95
Fried Chicken Dinner mashed potatoes & corn on the cob   17.25
Nag’s Head Veggie beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad   13.50
Choose Any Four Sides $14.50

Sides

Potato Salad    4.25
Cole Slaw    4.25
French Fries    4.25
Sweet Potato Fries    4.75
Spiced String Beans    4.75
Black Eyed Peas with bacon   4.75
Corn On The Cob 2 ears   4.75
Mashed Potatoes with gravy   4.75
Macaroni & Cheese    5.50
BBQ Baked Beans with pulled pork   5.50
Candied Yams with walnuts   5.50
Collard Greens    5.50
Fried Brussel Sprouts    5.50
Wild Rice Salad    5.50

BBQ

All Of Our BBQ Is Smoked Over Hickory Wood For 5-12 Hours

BBQ Lunch Special choice of brunswick stew or house salad & choose from any style ribs, pulled pork, brisket, 1/4 bbq chicken or pulled chicken. served with choice of two sides   14.95

Platters

Served With Two Sides, Cornbread & Pickles. Your Choice

St. Louis Style Ribs served half rack   22.50
Northern Style Ribs smoked & then grilled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   22.50
Southern Style Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s memphis style rub   22.50
Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s signature rub tastes like a country sausage   22.50
Carolina Pulled Pork pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s carolina bbq   16.95
Pulled Chicken smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   16.75
Sliced Brisket smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled   17.95
1/2 BBQ Chicken smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   17.25
BBQ Meatloaf beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked   15.95

 

Dinner

Beginnings

Hush Puppies with maple butter   7.25
Fried Okra with spicy dipping sauce   8.50
Fried Green Tomatoes with spicy aioli   8.25
Frickles with horseradish sauce   7.95
Peel & Eat Shrimp with lemon & old bay   12.50
Popcorn Shrimp with cajun mayo   9.75
Onion Straws    7.50
Spinach And Artichoke Dip    10.25
Jimmy’s Burger Shack ‘Minis’ choose one style: 3 per order cheeseburgers, turkey burgers & fried buffalo chicken sliders   10.50
Quesadilla with salsa & sour cream pulled pork or bbq grilled chicken   9.50
Rib Tips northern style   9.50
Bucket O’ Tips    17.50
Hot Wings buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked   9.95
Bucket O’ Hot Wings    17.50
BBQ Wings two part wing smoked & grilled in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   10.50
Chicken Fingers original, buffalo or chipotle   9.25
Jalapeño Poppers homemade & stuffed with a mixture of cream cheese & spices served with ranch dressing   9.25
Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Humongous Nachos chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole   12.50

Salads & Stews

House Salad    6.95
add chicken any style   3.00
add pulled pork   4.00
Chopped Cobb Salad lettuce, onion, tomato, buckboard bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken   12.95
Jimmy’s Wedge iceberg lettuce, buckboard bacon, diced tomato, smothered in blue cheese dressing & covered with onion straws   9.50
The Wright Salad romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette   10.95
add grilled chicken   3.00
Brunswick Stew a tomato based southern stew with corn, smoked chicken & pork   5.75
Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Chili topped with melted cheddar, served with sour cream & onion   6.25

Sandwiches N’ Burgers

With 1 Side And Pickles

Po’ Boys blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread with lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo   10.75
BBQ Grilled Chicken basted with bbq sauce on a roll with lettuce, tomato & onion   9.95
Fried Chicken buffalo style or original on a roll   10.25
Burgers    9.75
add chili, bacon or cheese   1.00
BJ’s BBQ Burger grilled with chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped w/ onion straws   10.75
Press’D Bourbon BBQ Brisket with bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast   10.75

Sandwiches

With 1 Side And Pickles, Slaw $0.50 Extra.

Carolina Pulled Pork    10.50
Pulled Chicken    10.50
Sliced Brisket lean or marbled   10.75
BBQ Meatloaf on grilled texas toast with tomato   10.25

Southern Specialties

Country Fried Steak With Gravy mashed potatoes & corn on the cob   17.95
Fried Chicken Dinner mashed potatoes & corn on the cob   17.25
Steak N’ Fries grilled skirt steak with homemade steak sauce & hand cut fries   20.50
Blackened Chicken grilled zucchini & squash   16.95
Blackened Catfish collard greens & mac n’ cheese   17.95
Nag’s Head Veggie beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad   13.50
Choose Any Four Sides $14.50

Sides

Potato Salad    4.25
Cole Slaw    4.25
French Fries    4.25
Sweet Potato Fries    4.75
Spiced String Beans    4.75
Black Eyed Peas with bacon   4.75
Corn On The Cob 2 ears   4.75
Mashed Potatoes with gravy   4.75
Macaroni & Cheese    5.50
BBQ Baked Beans with pulled pork   5.50
Candied Yams with walnuts   5.50
Collard Greens    5.50
Fried Brussel Sprouts    5.50
Wild Rice Salad    5.50

BBQ

All Of Our BBQ Is Smoked Over Hickory Wood For 5-12 Hours Served With 2 Sides Cornbread And Pickles. A Half Rack Of St. Louis Style Ribs

Northern Style Ribs smoked & then grilled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   22.50
Southern Style Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s memphisstyle rub   22.50
Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s signature rub tastes like a country sausage   22.50
Combo Rib Platter choose from our 3 styles of ribs, ‘lil’ more than a half rack   23.50
Carolina Pulled Pork pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s carolina bbq   16.95
Pulled Chicken smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   16.75
Sliced Brisket smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled   17.95
1/2 BBQ Chicken smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   17.25
BBQ Chicken & Ribs    19.50
BBQ Meatloaf beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked   15.95

Jimmy’s Pig Pick $25.95

Choose Any 4 Items From The Following Selections:

Northern    
Southern Or Dry Rub Ribs    
Pulled Pork    
Brisket    
BBQ Chicken Or Pulled Chicken served with hush puppies and cole slaw   

 

Brunch

Brunch Special $13.95 - Choice Of Eye Opener, Coffee Or Tea With Any Brunch Entrée

BJ’s Egg Sandwich* 2 fried eggs, ham, bbq onions & cheddar cheese on a jumbo english muffin served with home fries   8.95
Omelets* choose 2 fillings: bacon, ham, sausage, cheddar, gruyere cheese, bell peppers, corn, tomato & onion served with home fries   10.25
each additional filling   1.00
B.L.T. applewood bacon, lettuce & fried green tomatoes on country white bread served with french fries   9.75
Steak N’ Eggs* grilled skirt steak with homemade steak sauce, fried eggs & home fries   11.95
Chicken N’ Waffles cornmeal waffle with fried chicken breast & pure maple syrup   10.50
Bourbon French Toast with bourbon pecan syrup   8.75
Grilled Cheese cheddar cheese & apple wood bacon served with french fries   8.95
Shrimp & Grits shrimp sauteed with garlic & scallions over grits   11.95
Substitute Egg Whites For $1*

Beginnings

Hush Puppies with maple butter   7.25
Fried Green Tomatoes with spicy aioli   8.25
Frickles with horseradish sauce   7.95
Spinach And Artichoke Dip    10.25
Jimmy’s Burger Shack ‘Minis’ choose one style: 3 per order cheeseburgers, turkey burgers fried buffalo chicken sliders   10.50
Rib Tips northern style   9.50
Bucket O’ Tips    17.50
Hot Wings buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked   9.95
Bucket O’ Hot Wings    17.50
Quesadilla with salsa & sour cream pulled pork or bbq grilled chicken   9.50
Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Humongous Nachos chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole   12.50

Salads & Stews

House Salad    6.95
add chicken any style   3.00
add pulled pork   4.00
Chopped Cobb Salad lettuce, onion, tomato, buckboard bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken   12.95
The Wright Salad romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette   10.95
add grilled chicken   3.00
Brunswick Stew a tomato based southern stew with corn, smoked chicken & pork   5.75

Sandwiches, Burgers N’ More

With 1 Side And Pickles

Po’ Boys blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread with lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo   10.75
BBQ Grilled Chicken basted with bbq sauce on a roll with lettuce, tomato & onion   9.95
Fried Chicken Dinner mashed potatoes & corn on the cob   17.25
Nag’s Head Veggie beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad   13.50
Fried Chicken buffalo style or original on a roll   10.25
Burgers    9.75
add chili, bacon or cheese   1.00
BJ’s BBQ Burger grilled with chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped with onion straws   10.75
Blackened Catfish collard greens & mac n’ cheese   17.95
Press’D Bourbon BBQ Brisket with bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast   10.75

Sandwiches

With 1 Side And Pickles, Slaw $0.50 Extra

Carolina Pulled Pork    10.50
Pulled Chicken    10.50
Sliced Brisket lean or marbled   10.75
BBQ Meatloaf on grilled texas toast with tomato   10.25

Sides

Grits cheese or plain   3.95
Fruit Salad    3.95
Ham, Applewood Bacon Or Country Sausage    4.95
Home Fries    3.25
Waffle    5.00
Two Eggs    4.00

Sides

Potato Salad    4.25
Cole Slaw    4.25
French Fries    4.25
Sweet Potato Fries    4.75
Spiced String Beans    4.75
Black Eyed Peas with bacon   4.75
Corn On The Cob 2 ears   4.75
Mashed Potatoes with gravy   4.75
Macaroni & Cheese    5.50
BBQ Baked Beans with pulled pork   5.50
Candied Yams with walnuts   5.50
Collard Greens    5.50
Fried Brussel Sprouts    5.50
Wild Rice Salad    5.50

Eye Openers

Bloody Mary garnished with pickled string beans olives, celery & rimmed with our special rimming spice   9.00
Rise & Shine: Try It In A Fish Bowl vodka, oj, & a drizzle of grenadine  8.00 22.00
Hair Of The Dog a classic mint julep with makers mark bourbon & fresh mint   9.00
Bloody Beer budweiser, tomato juice, tabasco, worcestershire & fresh lime   6.00
White Peach Sangria    9.00
Mimosa    7.00
Bellini    7.00

Platters

Served With 2 Sides Corn Bread And Pickles. A Half Rack Of St. Louis Style Ribs

Northern Style Ribs smoked & then grilled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   22.50
Southern Style Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s memphis style rub   22.50
Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs smoked with brother jimmy’s signature rubtastes like a country sausage   22.50
Carolina Pulled Pork pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s carolina bbq   16.95
Pulled Chicken smoked & pulled with brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   16.75
Sliced Brisket smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled   17.95
1/2 BBQ Chicken smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce   17.25
BBQ Chicken & Ribs    19.50

 

Drink Menu

Bottled

Abita amber   7.00
turbo dog   7.00
Flying Dog snake dog ipa   7.00
Magic Hat #9    7.00
Saranac black and tan   7.00
Sierra Nevada pale ale   7.00
Amstel Light    6.50
Blue Moon    6.50
Corona    6.50
Hard Core Cider    6.50
Heineken    6.50
Heineken Light    6.50
Bud    5.50
Bud Light    5.50
Miller High Life    5.50
Miller Lite    5.50
O'Doul's    5.50

Cans $4.50

16oz

Natural Light    
PBR    

Draft

Pitcher $6.50, $22, $5.50, $18

Brooklyn Pennant Bud Ale    
Bud Light    
Sam Adams    
Sam Seasonal    
Shock Top belgium white   
Stella    
Yuengling    

Soda Pop

Boylans Soda grape, orange, ginger ale, root beer, diet root beer, black cherry   3.00
Coke    3.00
Diet Coke    3.00
Sprite    3.00
Fiji Water    3.00
Cheerwine Cherry Soda a carolina favorite since 1917   3.00
Cheerwine Ice-Cream Float    5.00

Tequila

Jose Cuervo    
Cuervo 1800    
Milagro    
Sauza Hornitos    
Patron Silver    
Herradura Añejo    
El Tesoro    
Reposado    

Bourbon

Jim Beam    
Bakers    
Bookers    
Basil Hayden    
Knob Creek    
Rebel Yell    
Blanton’s    
Wild Turkey    
Maker’s Mark    
Maker’s 46    
Elijah Craig 12    
Woodford Reserve    
Fighting Cock    
Heaven Hill    

Top Shelf

Johnny Walker Blue    45.00
Johnny Walker Gold    25.00
Macallan 18    30.00
Hennessey XO    35.00
Patron Platinum    40.00
Don Julio 1942    25.00
Jose Cuervo Reserve De La Familia    20.00
Milagro Select Barrel Anejo    18.00

Concoctions

Served In A Jumbo 16oz Mason Jar Or In A Pitcher

Plantation Punch a carolina rum runner containing sailor jerry’s spiced rum and coconut rum  9.00 31.00
Carolina Cooler brother jimmy’s classic cocktail made with vodka, lemonade and blue curacao  8.00 28.00
Drunken Sailor sailor jerry‘s spiced rum, cheerwine, sprite and cherry garnish  9.00 31.00
Louisville Lemonade a whiskey infused glass of lemonade made with maker’s mark bourbon, triple sec and sprite  9.00 31.00
Charlotte Tea a southern version of a long island iced tea made with five kinds of booze and a hint of the tropics  10.00 34.00
The Charleston A.P. south carolina sweet tea infused vodka, fresh lemonade and a splash of soda  9.00 31.00
Myrtle Beach Margarita a jumbo margarita either frozen or on the rocks add a flavor: strawberry, raspberry, peach or mango  9.00 31.00
The Grand Strand Margarita a top shelf margarita made with milagro silver tequila, grand marnier and lime  14.00 44.00
The Battle Of Antietam Bloody Mary a classic spicy bloody with a festive array of garnishes and a taste of the old bay   9.00
Jimmy’s Ole’ Fashioned our twist on the classic; jim beam, grand marnier and muddled fruit   9.00

Party Drinks

Swamp Water our legendary cocktail served in a 64oz fish bowl. hasn’t changed in 20 years!!!   20.00
Trashcan Punch 2.5 gallons of high octane punch served in a mason jar a perfect drink for a party!   90.00

 

Brother Jimmy's
181 Lexington Ave
At 31st St
(212) 779-7427
or (212) 288-0999
Advertising
© 2002-2011 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer