Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Brooklyn Diner

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Diners & Coffee Shops
  • 212 W 57th St, New York NY10019 40.7658156 -73.9807389
  • (Btwn Broadway & 7th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 977-1957
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 61 reviews)

Food 4.3 Value 3.3
Service 4.1 Atmosphere 3.8

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 977-1957
Major Credit Cards
Mon: 7am-11pm Tue-Fri: 7am-12am Sat: 8am-12am Sun: 8am-11pm
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
Delivery, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out, Catering
Delivery Area:
52nd St to Central Park S Madison Ave to 10th Ave

User Reviews

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by anonymous on 08/07/2009

    Best hot dog in NYC

    Although the place is overpriced, even for a New Yorker, they do have the best hot dog in the city. Skip the frizzled onion rings (they're greasy and soggy) and just get the hot dog and kraut. It's HUGE, but also excellent. Take it from one who knows! I agree the burger is also good. Pastrami is not good - skip it.

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by Geraci on 07/13/2009

    Fantastic Service!

    I'd had a difficult day and was very tied when I literally stumbled upon Brooklyn Diner. My plans called for eating in my room, but I had read the reviews and decided to try it out. I'm glad I did so. When I told my waiter I was both dehydrated and in need of a stiff drink, he ensured my ice water and my Midnight Manhattan were delivered posthaste. I had a Buffalo Mozzerella salad and the grilled Romanian tenderloin. The sea salt brought a really nice tang to the salad and the steak was divine. My corpuscles realy needed that boost. I will return on my next visit to Manhattan.

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by Ron on 06/26/2009

    Breakfast in Manhattan

    We were typical tourists, and I have to say we were really disappointed. Polenta and no potatoes available for breakfast? I expected the prices to be high, but there are a lot of Diners in Albany that have breakfasts that are a lot better than this for less than half the price. It must be a tourist trap. Service was mediocre at best, even though it was not busy when we were there.

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by MAG on 01/04/2009

    No Deli Here

    Restaurants can display different personalities. They can be fast, romantic, exciting, or show off wacky themes. The one thing all restaurants must do is to prepare and serve a delicious meal at a reasonable cost. The Brooklyn Diner which I have visited on several occasions almost hits the target. My biggest issue with the Brooklyn Diner is their overpriced items on their menu. Their service is efficient and friendly, The restaurant is clean, but small for the amount of customers that they must seat. As for the food, their Cheeseburgers are very good. I ordered this on several occasions and each time the Cheeseburger was prepared as I had ordered it. On a different occasion I ordered the Pastrami on Rye Bread. Unfortunately the Pastrami was mediocre at best. The price of this sandwich is overpriced for the quality of the food being served.. If you are going to charge high prices to your customers please have the quality of food to match the price. I would recommend the Brooklyn Diner if you desire a very good Burger during off peak dining hours. There are several old school delicatessens in the city that will serve delicious deli fare, that far outshines the Brooklyn Diner

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/03/2009

    Not what it used to be...

    I have been going for many years even ordering in but hadnt been in a few months. Sorry to say prices went up drastically and the service was much less than those prices deserve. Took forever to get correct wine....had to ask for water refills...burger was overdone...that kind of thing. And the burger...always a standby for me but now it has less to offer than when it was $12 and its now $17. No more brioche bun. No more onion rings. It was a very average burger and fries for so much money...sorry! In these tough times that is going to keep me away.

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by Sue from FL on 12/09/2008

    The Best-9 months later

    I had the pleasure of meeting a friend from childhood at the Diner in March for dinner. It was so good that a friend of mine from Florida who was in NYC with me to sing at Carnegie Hall asked me to join him for dinner the next night after we finished our performance. Both dinners were the most enjoyable we have ever had in all areasfood, service, atmosphere, etc. We are still talking about it, and trying to find a way to get back to NYC just to return to THE diner! Ok, so we'll probably do other stuff too (we've now sung at Carnegie 2 years in a row) because everyone knows there is so much to do and see in that great city, one can never do it all! Wouldn't it be wonderful to have a Brooklyn Diner in Lake City FL?? Anyway, thank you, thank you for the wonderful memories.

  • Brooklyn Diner

    Posted by Mike on 10/25/2008

    Going Downhill

    I have been a customer at the Brooklyn Diner for years. Recently -Oct 08- my wife and I went there for breakfast. The majority of the servers seemed to have changed. Also the young lady who welcomed guests was new. We waited about 25 minutes for breakfast to be served and when I questioned the waiter, he was surly and indignant. We argued and I said I wanted to talk to the manager. That never happened. We finished our breakfast and the waiter never returned. The bill was provided by the young lady who welcomed us in. We discussed the waiter's nasty disposition and she simply said she was sorry. I do not intend to go back to the Brooklyn Diner. The waiter ended my patronage. Also the coffee is extremely weak and refills don't come unless you stop a waiter and ask. Sorry to say, the food and service has seriously deteriorated.

3,000+ menus from the world's most diverse neighborhood.
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer