Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Broadway Pizza & Restaurant
Posted by Morningsider on 04/18/2014
What kind of idiot rates a pizza place on it's Buffalo wings? The pizza here is solid, whether it's an entire pie or just an emergency slice. Toppings are fresh. Spinach, eggplant, etc. are clearly prepared daily and aren't some frozen slop. They bake calzones and strombolis to order in a reasonable amount of time. Twice over the years when they've made a mistake with a delivery order, they sent along the corrected order without any fuss and said just to keep the first one no charge. Humble/shabby decor not conducive to a family dinner, but as regular pizza joint it remains the best in the neighborhood.
Posted by NYCcritic on 08/24/2012
The pizza has gone down hill in the past 2 years. Stopped in here the other day to give it another shot. Unfortunately, its still below average. The slices are small and bland. Not worth the trip here.
Posted by Anonymous on 05/25/2012
Buyer beware: expensive and not very good. Plus, the buffalo wings on the menu was nothing more than little fried chicken sticks, overbook with no buffalo sauce. And, the pizza was just okay. The service is poor. Much better options in the neighborhood.
Posted by kcs on 03/21/2012
Ordered a pizza tonight--50 minutes later I was still waiting and I called. I was told, "It's still here...delivery soon". Soon? How long does it take to make and deliver a pizza? I had company. Never again!
Posted by PizzaExpert on 10/07/2010
I used to go to this place when I lived in the neighborhood mostly because it was convenient and decent quality. I was walking past this place the other day and figured I would grab a slice. I was extremely disappointed. Perhaps its under new mgmt as it was renovated recently but the pizza was of poor quality. My 2 biggest complaints were that there was barely any sauce on it. It was almost like eating grilled cheese on pita bread. Second, the slice was tiny and I mean TINY!!! Not only was it tiny but it was extremely thin. What a waste!
Posted by Luigi Procino on 09/09/2009
The guy behind the register is super friendly so are the others. He will make your order exactly the way you want it. All the veggies are fresh, with the fact that they use great quality mozzerela cheese. Many pizzarias have lost the art of making a thin semi-crispy slice, these guys still do it. These guys still make the true New York slice.
Posted by Plenty of Shrimp on 07/22/2009
...where's the sauce? My delivery order arrived quickly, which was much appreciated. The toppings, while pricier than those at other neighborhood pizza joints, were ample and of high quality. Crust was decent: fairly thin/crispy without being burnt or soggy. My primary (only) complaint is that there was basically NO tomato sauce on my pie. If I'd wanted a white pizza, I would have ordered one! Bummer.