
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by Olya on 02/05/2012
Gargiulo Burger Madness!
Love it. I was excited because I saw the burger featured on Man v Food. PROS: 1) Decent pricing 2) Cordial, friendly, positive, caring, prompt, polite, and professional staff. Everybody greets you, smiles, asks how the service has been, etc. If these people are having a bad day, you'd never know it. 3) Small woodsy-lookin' space. Love those. There's never more than 2 occupied tables whenever I'm there. Great place for conversation, calm place to eat. 4) GARGIULO BORGER, THE - double dipped. YEAH. Soggy bread never tasted so heavenly. That's what I'm talking about! Don't ask. Just eat. Once the patty was a tad dry, but the sogginess of the bread made it juicy. 5) Tried a FRANKFURTER yesterday. Grilled. Rustic. Smokey. Wish they had cool toppings for it besides the Bostongurka/Indian (?) (green relish). but it taste great on its own. The bun felt like it was a day/two old. Don't think they make their own buns. 6) Small but well executed menu SO FAR. Next time I'll try a cup of Beef Broth or Wing Dings. CONS: 1) I like my light veggie salad wherever dine. They don't have any salads. Nada. 2) There's a menu on the wall with prices. There's a menu on the stable without prices. There's no explanation of ingredients in each dish. Just the names. The waiter will explain, but I like it in text-form. 3) Hours of operation don't make sense. Mon-Thu: 11am-1am Fri-Sun: 11am-7pm... seems it ought to be the other way around. ----------------------------------------------- BOTTOM LINE: Go try the Gargiulo Burger, double-dipped and the frankfurter... without the bun.
Posted by maddy on 09/09/2011
no big deal
it was no big deal whellers has better food .and a great price his hamburgers and roast beef are out of this world.
Posted by Steve on 10/08/2010
Great sandwich
The roastbeef sandwich was great dipped and the onion rings were excellent, will be back
Posted by dpdp on 09/03/2010
still good
the roast beef au jus isn't as big as it used to be, but still delish....way better than any fast food chain & about the same price
Posted by Big Lou on 06/22/2010
Good, not Great
The roast beef is very good. I tried it dry, dipped and double dipped just to really get the taste. The roast beef by itself is good not great as it is thought to be. Alot of the taste comes from the ajus. I loved the fried topped with cheese and gravy, very tasty. I would say that if youre ever in the neighborhood and want to stop by go ahead, just dont go out of your way to go there cause it is nothing special. I also felt like they did not want me there sitting at their table, not very friendly.
Posted by Jerry S on 05/16/2010
If you live there ok! If you dont, do not bother!
Asolutely nothing special about the steak sandwich dipped or not...It lacked taste, The roast beef itself was good, the so called A-JUS is awful...Now the fries 3.25 for a tiny oil logged plate. Don't waste your time.
Posted by Chrissy on 04/13/2010
Best Roast Beef in the USA
I'll have a bowl of broth, cheese fries, Roast Beef sandwich with an ice cold pitcher of beer please.