Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Posted by Happy Lady on 03/08/2012
Seated upstairs - pre-theater...Amazing waiter. I ordered 2 appetizers - grilled baby octopus salad - fantastic! And shrimp with some pasta - Delicious Boyfriend had salad and special tuna over Asian noodles - Loved it. Split Meyer Lemon tart - really really light and wonderful. Time to spare and they didn't rush us out. Nice surprise b/c last time I wasn't at all pleased -- good recovery!
Posted by Anonymous on 09/04/2011
Amazing service, great location, and great food!
Posted by Paula Hrankowski on 10/05/2010
The first thing I noticed was the decor. The waiter thought it was normal that I asked the name of the architect. Yabu Pushelberg. I should have known as it was done in their wonderful modern style. A feast for the eyes each way I turned. I was invited to look around and none of the staff thought it was odd that I wandered about the two floors admiring the decor. But a restaurant is for food as well as ambiance. The waiter recommended the salmon and suggested it be served as the chef prefers, medium rare. I took him up on this suggestion and must say it was done perfectly. I was a bit worried about the brussel sprouts having memories of being forced to eat such things to get dessert. All four of us agreed, "the brussel sprouts are amazing". Wine was fantastic of course. I wouldn't hesitate to go back, except I live thousands of miles away. When I return to New York, this restaurant is on my "must do" list.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/27/2010
My friend and I were waiting for our play to start when we decided to go somewhere for a small lunch. I had heard good things about Blue Fin, so I suggested it. We came in and the hostess seemed nice enough. She told us that the brunch items all came with drinks and coffee/tea. We ordered at 1:15 and our waiter made us wait for 10 minutes before he bought our water glasses. I guess they only rinsed out their glasses for brunch, because ours reeked of eggs. There was no point getting a different glass because our waiter was apparently swamped (the restaurant was only half filled.) When it came time to our meal being served, my Caeser salad was over dressed but ok. My friend really liked her spicy tuna roll. The waiter came back while we were halfway done with our food not to ask if we enjoyed it but to rudely asked me what my question was. I was puzzled because I didn't have a question and I kind of wondered if my waiter was stoned or something. When I told him I didn't have any questions, he left in a huff saying he had come all the way back here to answer my question...ooookay. My friend and I ate fast and before I was done with my salad he came back with the check and said "You guys are seeing a play right?" Whoa, eavesdrop much? He said he would bring us coffee 'later' but guess what? We didn't get our coffee. I felt really uncomfortable with my server. We actually left a good tip, more than he deserved truthfully. The food showed promise so I might come back but avoid this waiter.
Posted by KW on 02/03/2010
Went here with a party of 7 for dinner. Overall all of the food was very good, the sushi was particularly good. Decent service, but not excellent. The only thing bad about the place is the location and crowd. Very energetic and crowded. The bar is simply not large enough to house everyone that is waiting for tables as well as the usual crowd. The space is nicely decorated and well thought out, however the acoustics lead to a rather loud environment. This is excellent for groups and a casual night out. I wouldn't bother for a romantic evening or the like simply because of the hustle and bustle going on. Overall though the food is what should bring you back.
Posted by Franklin on 02/02/2010
We went on a Monday night, so there was no wait when we walked in. The bar had a decent crowd for a monday. The service was great, and the food was good. Tha atlantic cod was phenomenal, and the salmon, was well, tasted like salmon, but nothing special. Its a bit loud, but not to loud to have a conversation without yelling. I would recommend it to someone for a good, mildly priced, dinner/date.
Posted by MARKHROTH on 12/07/2009
We very much enjoyed our meal at Blue Fin. Service was excellent and very professional. Food was delicious and prepared exactly as ordered. Prices are, well, what you'd expect in the neighborhood. We sat upstairs which, while hardly silent, was much quieter than downstairs, and less trafficked. We would definitely go back.