Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
Posted by food lover on 01/21/2013
Ill keep it nice and short. If you think this place is good, go to sacs pizzaria in astoria. I promise you its a lot better then this place and cheaper.
Posted by babs on 07/01/2012
If the pizza is fresh, it is ok! Don't ask for it to be heated, you get major attitude. They have the unfriendliest people working there!
Posted by don't do it on 06/27/2012
I live literally two block from this place and after multiple attempts, i can safely say that is place is POOR for delivery. i keep trying because there are limited options in this part of the city. If you go there you will get a slightly above average slice (only if fresh)... if you are getting delivery then... good luck!
Posted by zack! on 05/31/2012
My friends and I LOVE Bleecker Street Pizza ! Wherever we go in the City we include a stop here. Their Grandma slice ( thick and square with rich sauce and fresh basil ) is our favorite . It's cool to watch how a fresh Grandma pie gets ordered slice by slice so fast it disappears before your eyes. This place always has a line of hungry people and not too many tables but people's love of excellent pizza overrides a short wait !
Posted by Lysa P on 04/24/2012
I've lived in NYC for 15 years and always go here for the best pizza. They have fresh amazing pizza - the cheese is delicious and everything is always flavorful.
Posted by David on 12/11/2011
I have lived in the West Village for years and every time I walk by this restaurant, I am saddened to see all the people being tricked into thinking this could possibly be good pizza. I truly think there is a conspiracy about their so-called awards. The pizza here is of the lowest quality. The crust tastes like cardboard and the sauce is way sub-par. If anyone believes this is good pizza, I feel bad for you. Try going to Pepe's, Sally's, or Modern Pizza in New Haven to try real pizza. There are also tons of great places around the West Village area that makes a good pie. John's, Keste, and Arturo's to name a few. Avoid this place like the plague and don't be tricked by fake reviews and people not from here that don't know the first thing about pizza. More than angry, it makes me sad to think of the thousands of people that have been tricked into thinking this can pass for apizza.
Posted by bri on 08/09/2011
One of my co-workers heard that Bleecker Street Pizza won the title of the best slice in NYC in a survey by radio station 92.3......so we had to walk over ! Now hardly a day goes by without a contingent from our office trekking there for lunch. My favorite slice is the Nonna Maria. This is thin crust pizza with thick & rich sauce and fresh Basil . We come back to it again and again! Another good choice is their Grandma slice. It's their spin on Sicilian ( thick squre crust). Stop by for lunch or whatever and you will see a happy crowd of pizza-loving customers....maybe I'll be one of them!