Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Posted by Nancy on 07/02/2008
Our waitress (who talked a lot and said her mom was from Ohio) had the worst fake French accent and it was so annoying. Other than that, our two times eating here were good if you ordered the right food. The Canard a' l' Orange was fantastic as was the Coquilles St. Jacques. The Salade Citron had too many greens and just average in taste. The carmelized onion tart had tasty onions but the crust on the tart was too thick - I ended up picking out the onions and leaving most of the crust. The hamburger was overdone. We ordered cosmo's, wine by the glass and tap beer. Very drinkable - nothing spectacular.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/01/2008
I have dined here with a group twice and on both occasions, the dishes varied greatly. The other night, we had an excellent gaspacho special, excellent tarte aux oignons, but very mediocre salade Citron. The scallops & shrimp was fabulous, the sole was good, the duck was good - the preparation of the leg was interesting even if the meat in it was a little overcooked. However, the steak frites was disappointing. The steak was ok but the fries tasted like they had been pre-made and frozen! The lemon tart was good, the crepes were ok but the profiteroles were totally bland. We ordered different wines by the glass because of the variation in main courses and we were pleased with what was served. The service was good and the atmosphere was pleasant.
Posted by PhishyEel on 02/25/2008
My boyfriend and I ate dinner at the bar because we were in somewhat of a hurry. Our Stellas were cheap ($5!!!) and the food came fast. The burger was thick, deliciously seasoned, and perfectly cooked even the bun was perfectly toasted. The fries were dangerous! Our Salad Citron was delicious and fresh. The host was friendly and the bartender was sweet and attentive. The atmosphere of the diners was relaxed, but tasteful. Definitely will be back.
Posted by DJ on 02/16/2008
I came here last night for a date. When the host gave me a blank stare and walked away when I told him I had a reservation, I should have taken the hint and left. I managed to get his attention again and he told me to wait at the bar. Fair enough. The bartender took forever to take our drink orders, and when he finally made the drinks he neglected to give them to us, and just went back to making drinks for the tables. When we finally got seated 20 minutes later, the waiter was not competent and didn't even bother to tell us the specials. I ordered the stuffed chicken breast, which was tough as all hell and when I sent it back they just brought it back even more overcooked. Inedible. I would avoid this place if I were you.
Posted by Mike Bernkopf on 12/30/2007
I was a customer on the evening of 12/26 when I ordered the weekly special, the cassoulet. It never should have come to the table. The sausage was burnt and full of gristle, the chicken leg (which should have been duck or goose) was cooked beyond recognition and edibility. The mystery meats were not particularly succulent. The beans were excellent. I have not written before as I have been out of town; I didn't say anything at the time as I was hosting my daughter (who was in from out-of-town law school) and I didn't want tospoil her evening. I would have emailed this,but could find no e-address. I am fond of your restaurant, and would like to return often.
Posted by Natasha on 12/02/2007
I went to Bistro Citron and was served by one of the best waiters I have ever been served by in New York, We had a great dining experience, the food was excellent. We celebrated an occasiion, and the waiter was very helpful in guiding through the menu and the wines. He was extremely attentive without ever bothering us during out meal. I believe his name was Noel (that's what it said on the check). If you ever go there for a solid good French meal, do ask for Noel to serve you: he will make a good meal and Great One!
Posted by Laurie & Mike on 11/21/2007
We are almost hesitant to give this place such a good review. The service is fabulous. The food is unbelievable. Just go there and hang out there. Sit at the bar, have a wonderful meal and meet great people. A place to go for any occassion. Have fun there --- we certainly do.