Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by R.Hall on 11/12/2013
We were treated as if it was a privilege to eat there. The atmosphere is bizarre, with half a lacquered pigs leg sticking out of a meat grinder, and otherwise it's stuffy. to say the least. The food is unappetizing. The tomato sauce was either watery or bitter, and the manicotti was bland with an inedible layer of burnt parmesan cheese on top. I would avoid this place.
Posted by Umckete on 02/23/2013
I don't know what took me so long to go there. It was great. I was headed to the garden & really needed to find a place to eat before the game. I just had the main course & dessert. It was amazing. The food melted in my mouth and the service was terrific. I told them I had to get out in time for the game and they made it happen. The dinner was actually better than the game:0)
Posted by anonymous on 09/17/2012
Found this place by chance when I needed to find a place near the Garden for dinner. That's usually the worst area to find a decent place. Well, I will always go to Biricchino from now on. The server was a doll! I can't eat certain things and she quizzed me to make certain the chef would cook everything just the way I liked it. it was perfect! the salad was fresh and the tomato better than the farmer's market. the chicken cutlet was hot and delicious. I also got the cheese platter for one, it was so yummy and 3 of us shared it. overall, even if the food hadn't been wonderful I'd go back because they treated us like family. the price was great and the homemade truffles that came with the check were out of this world. I highly recommend this restaurant!
Posted by EveT on 12/20/2010
We took my sister and her husband here when they visited NYC on their vacation. I chose Biricchino sight unseen because it was one of the only places fairly near their hotel. It turned out to be great. Each of us ordered something different and we all commented how good the food tasted. The service was fine, the atmosphere not fancy but quiet and relaxed. The tables are far enough apart that you don't feel squished in. Overall, we really enjoyed the place and my husband & I will definitely eat here again any time we're in the neighborhood.
Posted by JusReen on 11/22/2009
The service was what killed the experience. Though the waiter was not rude, he was entirely inattentive. He barely spoke to us, was completely unprofessional and disappeared when it was time for us to go. This was an inconvenience for us as we had to be at MSG for a game... The worst part was that he never showed up and offered parmesan or black pepper on our dishes. Italian? WEAK! Otherwise, the food wasn't bad. Oh yea, frozen butter sucks. Where is the olive oil?!?
Posted by Kathy D. on 05/15/2007
To start, the homemade Bresaola and the warm crusty bread were delicious and it only got better from there. I had the Insalata Biricchino to start which was simply delightful. For dinner I had the Fusillo and my husband had the fish of the day which was Sea Bass. The dinners were both absolutely delicious and were presented beautifully. For dessert I had the Profiterole and my husband had Gelati. Again, both were delicious and the perfect ending to the perfect evening. The food, atmosphere, service and price could not have been better. I will come back many, many times.
Posted by Bette Zimwaldt on 02/15/2007
My friend and I dined on 2/15/07. The Bread was good and the butter was frozen as commented on buy other reviewers. The salad course was very good. We had the fish of the day, sea bass, and it was flavored with artichoke and something else and those flavors clashed to make it sour tasting. Dessert was a Napolian, skip that unless you like cheese instead of creme. Capuccino was weak. Service was very good, and this restaurant is so well located to trains and Madison Sq. Garden.