Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Billy's Bakery

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Desserts, Bakeries, Cafes & Coffeehouses
  • 184 9th Ave, New York NY10011 40.745325 -74.001845
  • (At 21st St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 647-9956
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 34 reviews)

Food 3.8 Value 3.4
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.8

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 647-9956
(212) 647-9953
Visa, MC, Disc
Mon-Thu: 8:30am-11pm Fri: 8:30am-12am Sat: 9am-12am Sun: 9am-9pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Kid Friendly, Late Night, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by Tabithanyc on 01/16/2009


    Gorgeous little bakery! We were spoilt for choice, but eventually decided on Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie ... OMG! and a Hello Dollies bar. Both were delicious, but especially the huge piece of pie! Nice staff, cute, quaint decor. Will visit again.

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by monkeymed on 11/02/2008

    great cake, tiny venue

    I always pick up cupcakes every time I visit NYChave been a loyal Billys customer ever since we lived here and bought our daughters first two birthday cakes here. Quality consistently excellent. Icing is really sweet (which I happen to like). Service usually pretty good. Not enough tables. For take home cupcakes, best in NY.

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by Ms. Im on 09/26/2008

    The Dream Cupcake

    I can't believe how good the cupcakes are at Billy's Bakery. I have yet to try out cupcakes at Magnolia so I can not make a comparison just now but the cupcakes here are phenomenal. The icing is just the right amount of sweetness and the cupcake itself is so moist and delicious. Every bite is like a festive parade. The colors of the icing is so cute and the store itself is very inviting. The service was great even though there were a good number of people gathered waiting in line for their deserts. It was a great experience and I've been obsessed ever since.

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/20/2008

    Magnolia who?

    I have always been a Magnolia fan. I have been hearing about Billy's for a while, but have not gotten a chance to try it until just now. Well I can honestly say that there is no need to ever go to Magnolia again. The cake here is beyond phenomenal, all of their choices are perfect. There are many recipes that are exactly the same as Magnolia, such as my favorites, the red velvet cake and the Oreo ice box...same recipe but BETTER! Improved upon! The flavors are just the same, only the cakes are SO MOIST, the one thing Magnolia lacked. PLUS they have so many choices Magnolia doesn't, banana cake being just one. If you are a Magnolia fan, you will DEFINITELY switch to Billy's after just one bite. PLEASE do yourself a favor and try it, you will NOT be disappointed.

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/05/2008

    Very poor service!

    I was VERY disappointed in the service I received at Billy's Bakery. I called ahead and they told me that I could come in and place an order and that it would be ready within the day ( 2 cupcakes decorated with iced wedding bells). When I got to Billy's (which is not in my neighborhood) they said they don't know who would have told me that information because they could not place a same day order or do special decorating on cupcakes. The girl that helped me was rude and acted as if I was crazy! I was VERY disappointed and thought this was very poor customer service. So I left without ever trying a cupcake...

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by woefully disappointed on 08/04/2008

    Don't believe the hype

    I have ordered cakes from Billy's twice and on both occasions, I was VERY disappointed with the cakes and the service. People have raved about their coconut cake, but when I ordered it, not only was I made to wait half an hour while they "found' it, when we served the cake, the icing was gluey and could best be described as sugar spackle. Assuming that this was an unfortunate and isolated incident, we ordered banana cupcakes the following year and were again terribly disappointed. The cupcakes were prepared very sloppily they had OBVIOUSLY been iced while warm as the icing was runny and had slid off . When we called to complain, we did not receive an apology, and instead of offering to replace the order, they gave us a "gift certificate" for 6 cupcakes (we had ordered a dozen). This bakery is fine for a sweet fix, but don't rely on consistency of quality.

  • Billy's Bakery

    Posted by Anonymous on 05/26/2008

    Amazing Banana Cake!

    Cupcakes, cookies, who cares? Order the Banana Cake, it's the best thing you'll ever eat in your life.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.