Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint (CLOSED)

Burger & Pizza Joint
  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Diners & Coffee Shops, Burgers, Pizza
  • 2175 Broadway, NEW YORK NY10024 40.782426 -73.980953
  • (At 77th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 362-9238
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 54 reviews)

Food 3.9 Value 3.7
Service 3.0 Atmosphere 3.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 362-9238
(212) 724-2010
Delivery Take Out Visa, MC, Disc ($15 Min)
Daily: 24hrs
Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Late Night, Lunch Special, Open 24 Hours, Outdoor Seating, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by jsadobo on 08/02/2013

    so sad

    So sad that Big Nick's closed. What a great place it was -- gritty, but honest and down to earth.

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by swiluws on 02/18/2013

    omg - the pizza!

    ok...it wasn't the cheapest pizza, and it certainly wasn't he quickest...but by far this was the most delicious pizza i have ever ordered - and ever eaten, in NYC. go Big Nicks.

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by UWS on 08/14/2012

    Not recommended

    Husband and I had our first date at Nicks 14 years ago. Food was good back then. Ordered take out for years. No more...ever! Not only has the quality of the food taken a dive, rubbery meatballs, salad w/barely more than lettuce, less meat on souvlaki and other sandwiches, they don't even put fresh basil on pizza anymore - but that doesn't matter because the crust is inconsistent and the sauce is more often than not - sour. Last night did it! A simple order of chicken souvlaki, pasta marinara with a salad - should have cost under $20 + tip. When it arrived, in addition to two items listed there was a huge dinner salad. I asked my husband how much the order was, he answered $29 + tip - he gave the delivery person $33. I asked to see the bill and it was for $24.40 but the $24 looked like $29. I called Big Nicks to let them know that the delivery person had received a $10 tip (he is the usual delivery person), and should have known it was overpaid. The uncouth person I was talking to said it wasn't their fault, we should have caught the mistake. After a few words of disbelief at the attitude, the uncouth person said he would send the delivery person back - he never did.

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by Joseph Bonnano on 06/03/2012

    Slackarsed Delivery

    Ordered large pepperoni which was ok but not that great. Tipped the surly delivery guy five bucks for a 2 block delivery. Total cost twenty bucks. Big Nicks a bit over rated. Worth trying elsewhere.

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by Chris, Malmö, Sweden on 10/20/2011

    Cool place in NYC

    I have been at Big N for three times. 1997, 2000 and 2010. I like the good food, cold beer, great value and best location at Upper West!

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by Big Liz on 08/30/2011

    Best burgers in NYC

    I have eaten here quite a bit over the years - and just ordered delivery again last night from there. I had the Madrid Burger with extra Tzatiki, and OMG it was awesome! Also love the Bistro burger (insanely great) and the Teriyaki burger with an added grilled pineapple ring. Sometimes they even throw in free baklava!

  • Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint

    Posted by kty on 08/03/2011

    Great delivery!

    This is my favorite place to order from on the UWS! Super quick delivery, hot delicious comfort food, and reasonable prices. I love their pizza, and their chocolate shakes are amazing (no one uses enough chocolate in NYC). Also love the meatball and sausage sub. It's not in my neighborhood, but I suspect I will drag friends up there soon.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.