Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Big Daddy's

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Diners & Coffee Shops
  • 1596 2nd Ave, New York NY10028 40.775777 -73.953065
  • (At 83rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 717-2020
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 75 reviews)

Food 2.8 Value 2.0
Service 2.3 Atmosphere 3.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 717-2020
Place Order:
Order From Big Daddy's for delivery & takeout
Major Credit Cards
Sun-Thu: 11am-11pm Fri-Sat: 11am-12am
Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Brunch, Catering, Delivery, Free Delivery, Kid Friendly, Online Ordering, Online Reservations, Open 7 Days, Outdoor Seating, Private Parties, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery Area:
72nd to 95th St; E End to 5th Ave

User Reviews

  • Big Daddy's

    Posted by Stevie L. on 01/09/2008

    fun with kids

    Went last friday night, going against my long held position of never going to a new restaurant until a month has passed since opening. My 8 year old was dying to go so I caved expecting the worst. SURPRISE.....it was a blast. Everywhere I turned was a slogan or a lunchbox or a photo which brought me back to yesteryear(60's70's & 80's). The trivial pursuit cards on the table with questions such as "the name of the doctor on lost in space is?" gave us lots of laughs as well. The service was fine but i'm sure they are going thru the expected bumps.... but why are some of you not expecting that...weird...this isn't a top restaurant who does a few weeks of friends and family dinners followed by a week of discounted food. Food seems expensive at first but my wife ate her kitchen sink salad for 2 days. I loved my lets make a deal sandwich(crispy tater tots were awesome) and my son gobbled up his burger and shake like it was his last meal. I don't know what childless couple would make this a regular spot in their rotation no matter what the service was like.....it's fun(fattening) food and the families will make this place money. Go with the kids....or go for breakfast/brunch... and have fun!!!!

  • Big Daddy's

    Posted by Scott on 01/09/2008

    Fun Experience.

    My wife and I decided to try this new place for brunch, and really enjoyed it. It's a fun place with very reasonably priced food and good service. It can be a fun place for brunch, or to watch the big game since they have nice plasma tv's all around. Service was excellent as well. I would say we have another UES hit on our hands!

  • Big Daddy's

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/06/2008

    Ok food, extremely poor service

    My friend and I decided to check out Big Daddy's yesterday morning. First of all, for some reason the place opened at 11 a.m., so it was completely mobbed when we walked in at 11:15. We got a table pretty quickly, however that was the best service we saw during our whole meal. Once our waiter finally made his way over to us he appeared to have no idea what was on the menu, or have any serving experience in general. He repeatedly misstated the meal that my friend wanted. Then, super-shocker, she did not get the meal she ordered. In fact, we checked the menu and it looked like she didn't receive anything that was on the menu. After tracking down our waiter again, he did apologize for the mistake and offer to get her new food, but admitted that it would probably take another 20 minutes to come out (by the way, she never saw her side order of home fries). My waffle tasted like something I could make out of a box at home, and the strawberry used as "garnish" was way past its prime. The only high note of the meal was the waiter comping most of our food. By the end of the meal the restaurant had become so crowded with people waiting for tables that the crowds were encroaching on the diners and the screaming children were louder than the background music. If Big Daddy's is going to survive on the Upper East Side they are going to have to get their act together, and fast!

  • Big Daddy's

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/05/2008

    Great New Place

    Just wanted to say this is a great addition to the hood, great food, the service is a little spotty, but the place only opened a few days ago so thats very typical for a new restaurant, they are really friendly and helpful and great with kids i am sure they will improve over time.

  • Big Daddy's

    Posted by Upper East Sider on 01/03/2008

    New location - Disappointment

    I'm not going to lie, Big Daddy's is very inviting from the outside with bright glowing lights and a lively atmosphere on the outside looking in. Unfortunately, this is where the positives end. My GF and I were walking by the newly opened Big Daddy's at 83rd and 2nd avenue and decided to give it a shot. Because we live in the area, if we enjoyed our experience, it could be a real staple for us going forward. Boy were we wrong. From the get go, our service was delayed and then once we requested to see our server, we had multiple servers come up to us right after each other not having a clue that the other one had come. After all that, we ended up ordering our drinks with one server and our food with another. There was a nearby table that was so fed up with the service that they just walked out before their food arrived. One of the servers was really rude and it seemed like he was annoyed the entire time. We didn't feel very comfortable at all. After all the waiting and confusion, we got our food and it was average at best. Really nothing special at all. At the price point, the quality could have been better but maybe we ordered the wrong items. We had the tuna melt and the french dip. Both very average. I had a strawberry milkshake which was good. Not great, but good. All in all, I don't think Big Daddy's is a terrible place. I just don't think it has any real edge and the current wait staff there is really making a poor impression on the new customers in the UES. More than anything I was turned off by the poor service which ruined my experience and really gave me a poor outlook on the rest of my time there. My GF and I both agreed that because this is a location in the UES, it is very important to have loyal customers (not too many tourists). I think this diner is off to a bad start and I would recommend that it adds additional people to its wait staff so each server can be more attentive and just have a better attitude overall.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.