Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Bay Pizzeria & Ristorante
Posted by Diane on 11/23/2014
Been looking for a good Italian restaurant that delivers but never found one so for the past 10 years I've ordered from the other place on Sheepshead Bay Road. Never again. My neigbor told me to try Bay Pizzeria saying that they were the best. They truly are. After ordering twice I can say that the food is delicious, both the tomato sauce and the marinara sauce are thick, hearty and spectacular. The servings are generous . The people who work there are accomodating and will fix your order the way you want it. The food is delivered steaming hot and even the delivery boy is nice. He actually smiled, asked me how I was, and wished me a good day. I LOVE this place. No more thin, watery tasteless sauce for me. Try it.... and try their stuffed shells. You won't be sorry. Gotta go. I'm going to order again.
Posted by Frank G on 01/13/2013
The marinara sauce is homemade & amazing. A must have is the chicken pizziola slice, fresh mozzarella slice & the marinara slice is out of this world. I also enjoy the pasta with the homemade marinara sauce
Posted by anonymous on 01/20/2012
Have been coming here for years and have never been dissapointed. The pizza is great and the kitchen is delicious. Always fresh. Very clean. The workers are friendly and respectful. Definately would recommend for everyone to try. Convenient location and no minimum for delivery, can't beat that.
Posted by lisa smith on 04/02/2011
I am the biggest fan of pizza bay pizziera. It has the best and tastiest food in brooklyn. There are 2 brothers that work there and they have a lot of respect for the customers.
Posted by Anonymous on 04/21/2010
The Bay Pizzeria was between the subway and Dan's Grocery Store give or take a few stores. For 25 cents, I got a slice and coke to go. A pie was $2.00 and the sicilian pie was always more. I prefered the round pie and til this day, prefer a cheese pizza without any toppings. I am amazed that the place is still there. Fond memories back in the 60's. Moved in the 70's. There was the D Express Train and the Q Local Train. I still have old tokens.
Posted by Bill on 08/09/2009
Bay Pizzeria hands down has the best pizza in Sheepshead Bay. I've been going here for years, I ve tried the others, but their homemade sauce puts them far above every other pizza joint in the Bay. They're nice guys too, they support the community, the place is very clean and the service is terrific. They are located a few store fronts away from the BQ subway north exit.