Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Barnyard Cheese Shop

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Sandwiches
  • 149 Avenue C, New York NY10009 40.725554 -73.977983
  • (Btwn 9th & 10th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 674-2276
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 7 reviews)

Food 4.6 Value 4.4
Service 4.6 Atmosphere 4.4

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 674-2276
Major Credit Cards (Min. $10)
Sun-Wed: 9am-8pm Thu-Sat: 9am-9pm
Breakfast, Dinner
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Outdoor Seating, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by Brian Lee Boyce on 01/12/2014

    An East Village Treasure

    My newest Barnyard signature favorite is the Steak and Bacon Eggalicious! Add some cheddar and hold the jalapeƱos and it's a lunchtime dream come true. So hearty and a GREAT value at $8. Like all their sandwiches ( hot or cold) it's easily shared by two. Lots of other tasty selections, friendly service, and a true commitment quality make this place my East Village home for lunch!

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by SadButTrue on 11/19/2012

    Sad to say

    I LOVE barnyard & buy sandwiches about 3 times a week (minimum!). Unfortunately though, today was my last time buying from there. I've noted that in the past they have charged $8.50 or even $10.50 for my usual $6.50 sandwich (I always order the same thing). After being charged $10.50 again today I asked why the price difference? It's EXACTLY the same sandwich but depending on the person or the day the price ranges from $6.50-$10.50, which to me is a deal breaker. The always friendly guy in-store couldn't give me an explanation but just said that's how it works there and how they ring it up on the till & took my $10.50 regardless. I love Barnyard but it's the principle of the thing. You simply cant charge me $6.50 on Tuesday & $10.50 on Wednesday. I wonder if anyone else has experienced this price changing backwards & forwards. I will have to find another place nearby! Good luck to them though.. A loyal customer lost.

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by Peter on 01/18/2012


    An awesome addition to the neighborhood, Barnyard offers great sandwiches and gourmet products for reasonable prices. My friend got the Cuban Panini which he loved and for me, there was a pretty outstanding vegetarian option - the Farmhouse Cheddar Sandwich. Will absolutely be buying cheese by the pound here as everything is super fresh and high quality.

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by mspindell on 10/27/2010

    I love this place

    such a great place for the neighborhood. kind of a like a "gourmet" shop where you can get lots of different cheeses and stuff. the sandwiches and homemade empanadas are great and they also have these ridiculously great coconut macaroons (random?!)... definitely worth trying if you're considering it...

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/09/2010


    Its Not Great but not bad... Its that place you know what you are getting your self into... Ok Sandwiches for Ok Prices... That place where if u have no idea what u want for lunch u order from... Service and people there are friendly

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by Jake on 12/22/2009

    Fantastic - Just What We Needed

    The neighborhood needed this place. Their products are great and they have a great selection. I can't believe there's only 1 review so far. I would recommend everything there -- but the Greatest American Hero sandwich is seriously one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. They are always so friendly when I walk in and always have something interesting I want to try. Perfect!

  • Barnyard Cheese Shop

    Posted by anonymous on 12/18/2009

    great neighborhood shop!

    this is a great addition to the neighborhood. everything I've bought there was wonderful from the great selection of cheeses and meats to cookies and sandwiches

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.