MenuPages

I have been twice and both times I have been overwhelmed by rudeness and an in hospitality that stems from being cooler then me. poor showing once again

I saw Baked on the Martha Stewart Show and the Food Network. I had some high expectations. I purchased several items and some were good and others were mediocre. I had two least favorite items. First was their dark chocolate brownie. It was too cakey and dry. Also, the peanut butter cookie was too crumbly and dry. Maybe they were stale, maybe they were over baked or maybe they needed more shortening. In my opinion, a box of Duncan Hines brownie mix and Betty Crocker peanut butter cookie mix would have been better and less expensive (plus more for your money.) The best was their homemade whoopie pie was good. It was nice and light with subtle flavors. The rice crispy peanut butter and chocolate bar was OK, but it was heavy and too rich. That sums it up, Half-Baked....half was good and half was bad, hence mediocre.

It was a bit of a shlep to get to Baked NYC but it was well worth the trip. I had wanted to see if they had the smaller versions of the different cakes but they werent there. Instead I got some chocolate malt and pistaschio cupcakes and baked bars. The baked bars are truely yummy...better than magnolia's version. The pistaschio cupcake was delicious but sugar sweet makes the definitive version IMHO. If you live in the Red Hook area, its definitely a place to hit. I'll make a special trip on another occassion

This is the best bakery I've been to in my life. The cupcakes are to DIE for and so are all the cakes. We get the "birthday cake" for allmy friends and everyone loves it. The cake is light and buttery and the frosting is true buttercream. Not the heavy gross cement stuff that passes as buttercream at some other places. Try the red hot red velvet cake too. Amazing. The coffee is also top notch.

This place is totally amazing! I just went for the first time because it's next to my favorite brunch place and I was totally blown away by the cookies and homemade marshmallows. Try the chocolate cloud cookie. As my friend said, "It tastes just like a chocolate cloud." And the service is so so nice. This place is awesome. The cookies were expensive, but worth the money.