Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper East Side >
Posted by Anonymous on 02/08/2007
Have eaten here a number of times and the crab cakes are really among the best. made with real crab cake and nt stuffed with fillers/break crumbs. the oysters were also tasty. i got the crab-crusted snapper and it was very very good. desserts are good - the carrot cake was very nice with ginger ice cream. you will not be disappointed by the food in this restaurant. it's really that bill that will hurt more than anything but you can keep it down if you stick to a glass of wine and split dessert (if you even have room!)
Posted by Anonymous on 09/07/2006
The three entrees we had were outstanding. The salad was quite small for $11. At a restaurant as such we had to ask the waiter more than once for water and the busboy was a bit rude. A bit expensive but definitely worth a try . We had the tuna, halibut, and chicken on the main menu
Posted by muzzy63 on 06/25/2006
I have had approximately half a dozen meals at the atlantic grill. all of them have been fine; not great, not horrible. the prices are a bit steep but that is a reflection of the neighborhood. the restaurant fills up quickly so you do need to call ahead.
Posted by UESMK on 05/03/2006
Had great service during my first visit to Atlantic Grill. Our waiter was extremely attentive & knowledgable. It was a great atmosphere, as we were able to sit outside and people watch - always fun! However, although the food was good, I found the dishes a bit salty - especially the sauces. We got the Crabcakes & the Big Eye Tuna. Crabcakes & Tuna was great, however sauces and vegetables that accompanied the dishes were completely over-salted. As mentioned previously - this restaurant is quite pricey - and not quite as in proportion to the quality of food.
Posted by Anonymous on 03/22/2006
It's a large restaurant and busy every night. And there is a good reason for that. Locals know its the best fish and seafood on the Eastside. I am a regular customer there. There are efficient at delivering the food but call for a reservation, especially at popular times.
Posted by Nycitygirl327 on 03/12/2006
I've been to the Atlantic grill twice and its one of my favorite places in the upper east side. The crab cakes are simply delicious and the dessert is incomparable. I forget the name but there's this apple banana cinnamon tower thingy... if u have room for dessert its one of the best i've tasted. Over all, the Grill is on the expensive side but its worth it.
Posted by local customer on 02/21/2006
I guess my standards are a tad too high. I was surprised at seeing such a high rating for a basically overpriced average quality resturant. Money better spent would be to get in a cab or on the train and go down to another restaurant.