MenuPages

I had dinner here last night, and it was my fourth visit. We have always enjoyed the food and the service is top-notch. The staff is well trained and it shows, from the person who takes your reservation to the one who greets you and the server. All courteous and professional. The food is one of the best places in new york for seafood and portions are generous. A truly special dining experience.

Restaurant week is always a nice way to try something new. I have wanted to pop in here since it's right around the corner from me for awhile. Well..all was great. Service was quick and professional but I should add it was not busy at this time (Lunch).The food was fresh, hot, delicious and plated well for both me and my companion. I would suspect that it might get loud and cafeteria feeling if the space was fully occupied giving it's size and table arrangement. However, there are ample semi circle booths in the parameters that if snagged are a perfect compromise. Try it... I don't think you will be disappointed if you enter with this knowledge in mind.

Went recently for the first time. Although we try to avoid the area at "pre show time," we went for dinner at 6:45. Beginning with the person who took my reservation and continuing with the gentleman who greeted us and the waiter, all of the staff were courteous, professional and made one feel welcome. We were seated five minutes after the reservation time, had good service and excellent food. We will definitely be going back.

Food very good. However, we had to wait 45 minutes for the entree, 20 minutes for dessert. One salad (out of three) was forgotten. Extremely noisy room. Could not hear other people at my small table. At the end of 2 hours, had a splitting headache from the racket. Bathroom very dark. Were they hiding dirt, or just trying to be trendy? Will not go back.

I've visited Atlantic Grill three times for lunch before a Met performance. I've been very satisfied with all aspects of my experiences there. My reservations were always correct and I've been greeted by a friendly host each time. I've found the food to be excellent and the service to be very attentive. I've heard others speak glowingly about their experiences at Atlantic Grill, as well. I wish them continued success and hope to see them in this location for a very long time.

Had lunch there last week. Service was so poor that we actually had to call our waiter to place our order. The food was delicious as was the wine we ordered. However, we had to wait at least 15 minutes to get our food. The waiter was grossly dressed, unshaven, and seemed to be lost when we asked him about the horseradish.

Food is good. service is slow. Ambience is great but front room is very noisy. I had to shout for my wife to hear me across the table. Front desk person did not ask us about where we wanted to sit as they have a back room that was more intimate. I discovered it once I went to the bathroom. My chair got kicked at least 3 times by waiters as my back was facing the circulation path which was very very annoying. ....replace the cool white lighting on the fish/sushi counter as it makes everything look scary. Not going back there again.