Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Rae on 08/13/2008
I had dinner at Arturo's last night with my husband & a friend. We started out sitting outside but the rain drove us inside. The food was great, the waitress helpful and friendly and all in all it was a very good experience. I was torn between ordering the pizza which looked so yummy and a chicken dish. I went with the chicken dish which was lemony, hot and fresh. My side order of brocolli rabe with garlic was huge and also delish. My husband had the eggplant parm and our friend has the special which was grilled shrimp with risotto and asparagus. There were plenty of shrimp on the dish and he cleaned his plate. The decor was definitely old school but in my opinion, it only lent itself to the charm. Service was good, the food was good, the wine was good - what more do you want from a restaurant? Next time, I'm definitely going to have the pizza.
Posted by Simone on 04/18/2008
Again and again I read about Arturo's "poor decor". Guys, this restaurant has been there for 50 years now. The never changing decor is part of Arturo's image which most customers love and apprecciate.
Posted by hd on 01/04/2008
I'm not one of those people that goes out searching for the best pizza in NY, but this has to be in my top 3. We had the bacon garlic pizza and it was awesome. Didn't have anything other than the pizza so I can't comment on those dishes, but the place certainly smelled good. The decor doesn't offer much, but there is definately something to be said for the free jazz every night. Not many other pizza places in NY offer that.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/02/2008
This place is very popular and I have no idea why. First of all, the place looks like it hasn't been redecorated -- or cleaned -- since 1973. Second, our waiter was very inattentive. He brought us a flat Coke in a can, which isn't necessarily his fault or even the restaurant's fault, but it literally took 15 minutes for us to get anyone's attention to bring another one. Third, the place is overcrowded, which isn't a big deal at most places, but it mattered here because waiters and busboys repeatedly knocked into both of us as we sat waiting for our food. At one point a busboy knocked me hard with tray full of glasses and didn't even apologize. It hurt! Maybe we would have forgiven all of this if the pizza was good, but it's nothing special. There are better pizza places in the neighborhood, coal-fired oven or not. On the other hand, there was good, live jazz music playing in the front dining room near the bar. It seemed like there were roomier booths in there, too. If you want to try this place, hold out for a good table!
Posted by Anonymous on 11/01/2007
My friends and I stopped by Arturo's after the Halloween parade in the village. We ordered the pepperoni pizza (pretty standard) and had some wine. The food was delicious. Thin crust pizza baked to perfection. I would highly recommend this for a dinner out with the girls, or for a date. For the three of us, with a small pizza and two glasses of wine each, our bill came to about $26 each - pretty reasonable by new york standards. The atmosphere was also very nice - there was a grand piano, and the waiters sang some Frank Sinatra songs - totally unexpected! I would definitly visit again.
Posted by FoodConnoisseur on 02/27/2007
The pizza was delicious. It was not as thin as my girlfriend and I are used to but oh so yummy. The sauce was tangy, crust was charred(not burned) and smokey and the pepperoni was plentiful. One bite of the pizza the combination of tangy sauce, creamy mozzarella cheese, intense garlic, I knew it was in a league of its own. I couldn't stop eating it. The mixed green salad is also a good choice for appetizer.
Posted by L`M_NY on 02/22/2007
The prices are a bit too high for the amount of food given, however, the taste of the food is deserving of a return visit. Tim, the waiter, is also, a good reason to return. He remembers you upon your return and makes you feel welcomed with a warm hug and a concern of how you've been. His service is always exceptional. Thank you Tim! The cook has always been able to make special orders for me just the way I like them prepared. He does a great job. I don't know his name but he does in fact have gray colored hair and is a slim gentleman. Thank you Cook! As for the crowd, they give you the impression your part of the television sitcom, CHEERS! Everyone is always friendly and you get a smile when you walk in from anyone who might be sitting at the bar. The most interesting feature of all is the bathroom. You have GOT to see this bathroom. It isn't your normal everyday type of bathroom. We can't forget Sammantha the little four legged pussycat who comes out after everyone has left and checks out the place for inspection before she goes back down into the cellar and stands guard. Well, if you're ever in NYC. This is one place if even for historical purposes, you should put it on your "to do" list.