Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Anonymous on 10/27/2006
When it first opened this place was great - at least for the pizza - fantastic white pizzas, probably the best i've had. but upon multiple returns its just not the same - the pizza is soggy and not as tasty. Also ive had a couple of the pasta dishes and they were not good!! Penne Rabe & Sausage and another dish which was Marina with capers - I also agree with the other reviewer the prices seem steep considering decor and average dishes (both in taste and inventiveness). Iits a great shame because the boys who run and work at this joint are fabulous!
Posted by Hammer on 09/16/2006
Just ordered a large pizza for delivery. Twenty dollars later I'm still hungry. Not recommended.
Posted by kay. on 09/15/2006
I've been here a few times and have never been disappointed. The food is very good (and for a very reasonable price) and the service is fantastic! I once had to wait a mere five minutes for a table and the owner (?) gave us complimentary appetizers for our trouble! It’s not very ideal for large parties, but if you live in the neighborhood you should definitely try to check this place out.
Posted by olive on 09/08/2006
This is by far the best pizza in new york. Better than lombardi's even. And i disagree with other reviews--the service is fantastic and quick, and the waitstaff recognizes the regulars. The bread they serve before meals is soft and dense and delicious. Try the pizza with calamata olives--the best!
Posted by Karen on 07/28/2006
My family and I have eaten at Anthony's many times. The stuffed mushroom, eggplant chicken & chicken marsala are delicious! The atmosphere is comfortable, the staff is great, and the price is right!
Posted by J & J on 07/15/2006
Don't know what all the fuss is about this place. Maybe it's the kid factor (bring all you got). We've eaten here by default a few times and find it over rated. The service is amatuerish. Once I asked for olive oil to add to my caprese salad...they brought me balsamic vinegar! And that took 3 requests. Otherwise We find it all very average.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/02/2006
The pizza is very good, if you can stand the subpar service. Extremely inattentive waitstaff. I have given anthony's many tries. The waitstaff has been inatttentive every time. The last time i was in, the restaurant was practically empty - the server spent the whole time chatting with other servers. We had to get up and walk over to her to get her attention.