Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
Posted by Judi B. on 02/04/2012
I am never disappointed at Anthony's. I ate there this week and had a wonderful eggplant parm appetizer and also stuffed mushrooms. The pizza has fresh basil and delicious sauce and cheese. The crust is perfect. This was the first time I tried the cannoli...yum! It's ethereal with a lighter filling and a totally melt in your mouth shell. Very different from the cannoli's I've eaten my whole life in Bensonhurst. I hope to be enjoying the food at Anthony's very soon.
Posted by glad to find a great pizza on 12/04/2011
easily best pizza in park slope. yummy, bubbly crust, chunky sauce, nice veggies. probably the only reason you wouldn't have heard of it is they really don't seem to market it. is it coal or wood oven? who knows? they don't say on their site. and they don't even bring you a menu when they deliver. and the pizza comes quicker than they say.
Posted by Dominic on 05/19/2011
I had take out pizza, so my review is limited to that, and my opinion is - mmmmmm, at last, thank you! I've eaten across Italy & I've pizza'd all across NYC; I know the difference between right and 'meh'. Anthony's is Proper Pizza - it's all in the crust, and the toppings (which should be few but good).
Posted by N.Brown on 03/10/2011
Went to Anthony's and ordered the house pie. It was great. The crust was really good and the cheeses(I think they use 3 different kinds) tasted very fresh. Dessert was their homemade cannoli which was really good. Great dining experience overall. Will be back !
Posted by e6thave on 03/03/2011
The food was very good, although kind of pricey. I guess I was hoping for a more un-showy, humble, and inexpensive pizza joint. The service was attentive, almost to a fault (if that's possible in your mind). However, my low expectations aside, the overall message is the food is great.
Posted by LGeminder on 02/21/2011
unbelievable service (Omar was our waiter, and was great), food (sunday ragu), and cannolis.
Posted by Anon on 02/12/2011
Beware the Caesar Salad...for some unknown reasons, it tasted extremely fishy! It was so bizarre. I don't understand how or why, but I've never had a Caesar Salad that tasted fishy in my life...took one bite and had to toss the rest out. The pizza was alright...nothing special and overpriced...I've had much better pizzas elsewhere.