Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
Posted by Anonymous on 04/09/2013
Ordered a few times to go and they served me cold, not even reheated, pizza. When I complained I basically was cursed out by the guy who answered the phone.
Posted by Anonymous on 09/27/2011
Love this pizzeria... My favorite slices are the plain or the chicken ceasar slice ... Wow amazing! But then when i think about it.... every slice is delish ^_^
Posted by Anonymous on 04/15/2011
I previously ordered from this restaurant at least once a week, but lately quality of service and product has dropped dramatically! I ordered a pizza which I was told would be delivered within 30 minutes, lost track of time and when I looked at the clock it had been an hour and ten minutes... when I called to inquire about where my pizza was, I was told "just 5 or 6 minutes longer"... and then asked "what did you order?"... the hostess on the phone had no idea what I ordered! I will not order from this place again!
Posted by Anonymous on 07/24/2010
Hands down the best pie in the 'Burg! And the guys behind the counter will amuse you while you wait.
Posted by tabatha on 09/23/2009
i'm from brooklyn, raised here, lived in williamsburg my whole life, and the cheese pie/slice here is INSANE. i've heard people say it wasn't all-that, but they must have had something up their ass. and they deliver within 30 minutes!
Posted by C on 08/12/2009
Literally, we go there and don't even have to order...they tell us...BEST PIZZA EVER!!
Posted by Daveadler78 on 06/24/2009
I am a pizza junkie. When it's time to decide what to eat, a little voice in my head says, "Have some Pizza!" WAY more often than is normal. Because of my addiction, and because my job takes me all around the City (all 5 Boroughs, LI, NJ, Upstate, etc.), I have eaten at dozens of pizzerias around the area, all the local chains, all the places listed in tourist books, all the places that have been featured on Food Network, even the "secret" places in Bensonhurst and Yonkers and Arthur Avenue and elsewhere. Some of those places are pretty damn good, but Anna Maria is by far the best that I have ever eaten. The lasagna slice, the chicken parm slice, the meat lover's slice, the pesto and garlic-heavenly, every last one. Their slices are like entrees on a slice of dough-you need a knife and fork to eat them. Best sauces and toppings around. The place is a hole-in-the-wall and kind of dingy, so if you're a priss you might be a little put off. Trust me, just get over yourself, take your slices to go, and then plan your second visit.