Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

A Slice of New York (CLOSED)

  • Italian, Pizza
  • 727 8th Ave, New York 10036 40.759768 -73.988388
  • (Btwn 45th & 46th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 399-9555
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 11 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 2_5 Value 2
Service 2 Atmosphere 2

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 399-9555
Free Delivery Take Out Catering Cash Only
Daily: 10am-3am
Catering, Delivery, Lunch, Take Out

User Reviews

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by joan on 2012-05-08


    The poorest pizza I have ever had. They don't even heat it thoroughly.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by Gerry on 2011-12-09

    No Good

    My pizza slice was not heated properly - the cheese was still in small pieces instead of being melted. Honestly, the crust tasted like frozen pizza. I also saw them overcharge a customer, and then wouldn't refund her the overpayment.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by lauralewie on 2011-01-12


    We were looking for a "quick slice" before going to the theater, and there it was - A Slice of New York! My daughter and I both enjoyed our pizza very much, and we also were impressed with the very friendly little boy who was cleaning the tables with the

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by anonymous on 2009-07-07

    Absolutely the worst

    I live right around the corner from this place and have been in four times. The pizza is looks like it is a day old. The counter help is very unfriendly. But one of the worst things is that the pizza is VERY expensive. It is over 3 dollars for a plain sl

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by Retired pizza maker on 2008-03-06

    Bad service, bad pizza!

    Went there for lunch, asked for a chicken parmagiana hero..didn't have it. Asked for a meetball hero...didn't have it. I pointed to the menu and it was listed. The guy behind the counter said with an attitude "I know whats on the menu but we don't hav

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by NewYork1 on 2007-12-17

    Not recommended

    Went for lunch today and it was not a good experience. The guys behing the counter couldn't be less friendly if they tried. We got 2 regular slices, 1 specialty slice, and 1 drink for $12.85. My 2 regular slices were half warm and my girlfriend's speci

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by CityLady on 2007-08-24

    Not Worth Your Time or Money

    I recently went to "Slice" for a piece of pizza on my lunch break. Aside from the slices being priced exorbitantly, the man behind the counter was unhelpful and unhygienic. My boyfriend asked for a slice of cheese and was offered a day old slice with the

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by NYC07 on 2007-05-21


    A Slice of New York is an excellent place to get pizza in NYC.... The slices are enormous and the pizza was delicious... I'd reccommed it to anyone!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.