Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

A Slice of New York (CLOSED)

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza, Italian
  • 727 8th Ave, New York NY10036 40.759768 -73.988388
  • (Btwn 45th & 46th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 399-9555
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 11 reviews)

Food 2.4 Value 2.2
Service 2.1 Atmosphere 1.9

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 399-9555
Free Delivery Take Out Catering Cash Only
Daily: 10am-3am
Catering, Delivery, Lunch, Take Out

User Reviews

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by joan on 05/06/2012


    The poorest pizza I have ever had. They don't even heat it thoroughly.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by Gerry on 12/08/2011

    No Good

    My pizza slice was not heated properly - the cheese was still in small pieces instead of being melted. Honestly, the crust tasted like frozen pizza. I also saw them overcharge a customer, and then wouldn't refund her the overpayment.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by lauralewie on 01/11/2011


    We were looking for a "quick slice" before going to the theater, and there it was - A Slice of New York! My daughter and I both enjoyed our pizza very much, and we also were impressed with the very friendly little boy who was cleaning the tables with the biggest smile! I would highly recommend the restaurant!

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by anonymous on 07/06/2009

    Absolutely the worst

    I live right around the corner from this place and have been in four times. The pizza is looks like it is a day old. The counter help is very unfriendly. But one of the worst things is that the pizza is VERY expensive. It is over 3 dollars for a plain slice. I got a GYRO and the meat wasnt even off the skewer (think :one of those lamb gyro machines). The meat was sitting in a drawer. He put the meat on the pita bread and then heated it up. After it was out of the oven the meat was so hard you couldnt even bite through it. I had to throw it out.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by Retired pizza maker on 03/05/2008

    Bad service, bad pizza!

    Went there for lunch, asked for a chicken parmagiana hero..didn't have it. Asked for a meetball hero...didn't have it. I pointed to the menu and it was listed. The guy behind the counter said with an attitude "I know whats on the menu but we don't have it today". Actually went back on another day and tried the pizza. It was by far one of the worst slices I have had in this city. Just because the slice is huge it doesn't make up for the bad taste. My friend was unhappy with his slice as well.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by NewYork1 on 12/15/2007

    Not recommended

    Went for lunch today and it was not a good experience. The guys behing the counter couldn't be less friendly if they tried. We got 2 regular slices, 1 specialty slice, and 1 drink for $12.85. My 2 regular slices were half warm and my girlfriend's specialty slice was completely cold. At risk of bothering them, we had them reheated. Finally, we got to eat and the pizza was not very good at all. The ingredients in the pizza were either not fresh (at all!) or cheap.

  • A Slice of New York

    Posted by CityLady on 08/23/2007

    Not Worth Your Time or Money

    I recently went to "Slice" for a piece of pizza on my lunch break. Aside from the slices being priced exorbitantly, the man behind the counter was unhelpful and unhygienic. My boyfriend asked for a slice of cheese and was offered a day old slice with the remark "It’s all the same." Do not be persuaded to spend money in here based on the seemingly delicious window display. I will never again spend $15 on three slices of this pizza. Also, while we were eating a homeless man came up to our table and repeatedly asked us for spare change. Three workers at the pizzeria saw it and did nothing- which goes to show this happens a lot.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.